
pumping out plenty of power even
after 15 hours of use. One downside:
Replacing the battery will cost you
nearly as much as the radio itself:
$130.
Overall performance ratings on
the IC-M72 were Good to Excellent,
though it fell a bit short in two areas.
It scored only a Fair for transmitter
frequency stability because the trans-
mitter went off frequency by a small
amount after emerging from the heat
chamber. It was still within design
specifications and completely usable,
however.
Following submersion, we noticed
the battery compartment had some
minor water intrusion. According to
Icom advertising manager, Dave Kru-
zic, water in the battery area is not a
problem for Icom radios. “There is no
huge gasket between battery and radio
to prevent water intrusion. Where it
is important to protect against water
intrusion is where the battery contact
points meet the radio mainframe. If
you look at both the M72 and M88,
the gasket is small and only covers
this critical area. If you submerge the
radios with the battery properly fit-
ted in place, remove from water and
shake the radio off, you should hear
a small suction ‘snap’ when removing
the battery and the contact point seal
is disrupted. It should be dry in that
small area. The rest is unimportant.”
This radio is operated with a rotary
on/off/volume control located on top,
a push-to-talk and a squelch button
on the side, and six pushbuttons on
the front panel. Controls on the front
select transmitter power, channel
changing, weather, quick 16 or 9, and
scanning. An optional microphone
or speaker connects through a port
in the top.
Bottom Line: A well-built radio
with highly rated ergonomics, good
performance, and excellent battery
life. Battery replacement cost is high.
Icom IC-M88
This expensive sub-compact packs
a load of features into a lightweight
package about the size of a bar of soap.
The M88 operates by using the rotary
on/off/volume control located on top,
a push-to-talk and a squelch button on
the side. Six front-panel pushbuttons
control transmitter power, channel
changing, weather, quick 16 or 9, and
scanning. An optional external speak-
er/microphone plugs in on the side.
The M88 earned Good or Excellent
ratings across the board. During the
battery-life test it was one of only four
radios still functioning after 15 hours
and it was going strong even then,
pumping out plenty of transmitter
power during our final check.
This radio shares two less-than-de-
sirable traits with its sibling, the M72:
It has a very expensive battery ($122)
and it had some water in the battery
area following our dunk test. See the
Icom IC-72 text for Icom’s explanation
as to why water in the battery area is
not a big deal.
Bottom Line: A great performer,
but it’s expensive and so is battery
replacement.
Raymarine Ray101
At about twice the size of the diminu-
tive Icom M88, the Ray101 is the hefti-
est handheld in this test. It uses six
AA-size nickel metal hydride batter-
ies contained in a sealed battery pack
that fits securely to the back of the
unit. This setup gives the Ray101 the
lowest battery replacement cost in the
group, as well as the opportunity to
quickly install standard AA batteries
should the need arise. Unfortunately
this setup also yielded the worst per-
formance in our battery life test by
only lasting nine hours. Raymarine
communications manager Nancy
Baumgartner commented on the
Ray101 batteries. “Since the battery
is a consumable item, it is not covered
under the 3-year radio warranty. One
of the major advantages of the Ray101
is that it does not use a proprietary
battery pack; instead the consumer
can go to any retail store in the US and
buy regular AA rechargeable NiMH
batteries for a fraction of the price of
the proprietary custom batteries used
by other radio manufacturers.
Ray101 also allows flexibility for
the users to upgrade their batteries to
the bigger capacity battery. Upgrading
to the bigger capacity battery would
instantly increase the battery life and
make the radio up to date to the latest
battery technology.”
Two rotary knobs are mounted on
the top of the unit: an off/on/volume
control and a squelch control. The
side-mounted, push-to-talk switch
is too hard to press, in our opinion.
Seven front panel pushbuttons select
transmitter power, scanning options,
channel change, weather, panel back-
lighting, and quick 16.
Left: A few drops of water got inside of
the Icom IC-M88’s battery compartment
after our dunk test, but a gasket pro-
tects the battery-to-radio connection.
Comentários a estes Manuais